10 Best Mouse Traps 2025 in the United States

The Catchmaster Max-Catch Mouse & Insect Glue Trap is a sticky trap designed to catch mice as well as various insects like ants and spiders. It’s ready to use right out of the package and works by placing the glue board along areas where pests travel. One strong point is its safety: it’s pesticide-free, making it a good choice for homes with kids or pets where you want to avoid chemicals. The traps are also mess-free and can last up to a year if kept indoors in normal conditions, which makes them convenient and cost-effective for long-term use.

These traps don’t require bait, which simplifies setup, though this could be seen as less attractive for mice compared to baited options. They are intuitive to place and can be folded into a tunnel shape to protect the sticky surface if dust or debris is a concern. They suit users looking for a non-toxic, low-maintenance option and are especially helpful in places where snap traps or poisons aren’t allowed or wanted.

The glue traps catch pests alive and stuck, which can lead to prolonged distress before removal, raising humane concerns. This method may not align with everyone’s preference for more immediate or humane pest control. The traps are single-use; once a pest is caught, the board must be discarded and replaced. The size and material (paper with adhesive) limit durability beyond their intended single use. This product is well suited for homeowners seeking a straightforward, chemical-free way to catch mice and small insects indoors. It prioritizes safety and ease but involves compromise on humane treatment and reusability. For those wanting a simple, bulk solution without poisons, it is a reliable option, though alternatives might be preferred by those concerned about pest suffering.

The Tomcat Mouse Trap uses a glue-based design to catch mice and other pests like cockroaches and spiders. These traps come ready to use, which makes them very easy to set up—just place them where you've noticed pest activity, such as kitchen edges or basements. Since they're pesticide-free and non-toxic, they’re safer to use around children and pets compared to chemical traps. The glue has a strong, immediate grip that keeps pests stuck quickly, making it effective for capturing multiple types of small creatures without needing bait.

Because these are glue traps, they are single-use and disposable, so reusability is not an option. Additionally, glue traps are generally considered less humane since pests can suffer for some time before being caught and removed. For someone looking for a quick and easy way to reduce small pest problems without chemicals, these traps are practical and straightforward. However, if you want a more reusable or humane option, or a trap that kills instantly, you might want to explore other types.

The Tomcat Glue Trap is best suited for those seeking a simple, chemical-free solution that works immediately and covers various pests, though it sacrifices reusability and humane treatment in favor of convenience and effectiveness.

The Victor M156-20 Metal Pedal Snap Mouse Trap is a classic choice for those dealing with a mouse problem. Its simple design ensures ease of use, making it accessible for anyone regardless of experience. With a precise trigger mechanism, it offers quick and effective action, promptly eliminating pests upon contact. Its long-standing performance history, being used for over 120 years, speaks to its reliability and effectiveness in pest control.

The trap is versatile as it can be disposed of after use or cleaned and reused, providing flexibility based on user preference. Made from sustainably sourced FSC-certified wood, this product is environmentally conscious, appealing to those who prioritize eco-friendly options. It is also manufactured in the USA, which may be a point of interest for those preferring domestically produced goods.

While the trap is effective, the snap mechanism is designed for a swift kill, which may raise humane treatment concerns for some users who prefer non-lethal options. Additionally, as a traditional snap trap, it requires careful handling to ensure safety during setup and disposal, and may not be the best choice for those unfamiliar with setting traps. The Victor M156-20 is particularly suited for those seeking a reliable, straightforward, and cost-effective solution to mouse infestations.